Er and Onan

Genesis 38:6: “Judah got a wife for Er, his firstborn, and her name was Tamar.”

“It’s not my fault that my father picked you. I didn’t want to marry you. So don’t be surprised that I am rarely at home.” Er was drunk. He always liked to pick a fight when he had too much to drink. And today he was in an especially lousy mood. Tamar knew better than to say anything. She picked up her water jar and headed outside. Her husband called after her: “Where are you going?” Tamar turned around and looked at him. In his drunken state his face was flushed, his hair disheveled. Calmly Tamar responded: “I’m on my way to the well. I’ll be back soon.” He scoffed: “You’ll be back and I’ll be gone. I’m leaving.”

By the time Tamar reached the public well her face was wet with tears. Standing in line, one of her neighbors approached her. She knew what was going on and hugged Tamar. “Why don’t you come over and stay with us tonight”, she offered and Tamar accepted. It was not the first time that she sought refuge at her neighbor’s. Er lashed out whenever he was drunk. It was safer not to be around when he returned late at night.

The next day Tamar went back home and began to prepare a meal for her husband. Her heart was heavy. Honest to God, she felt trapped in her marriage. Her husband’s drinking and abuse had worsened over the years. Even though her father-in-law Judah had been blind to her desperate situation he had been kind to her. Before the wedding ceremony he had set some time aside to talk to her about the God of Abraham, Isaac and his father Jacob who now went by the name of Israel: “You are going to be married into the family tribe of the children of Israel,” he had said, “The all-powerful God who created heaven and earth has revealed Himself to our forefathers.”

Tamar felt desperate enough to pray to a foreign deity and said: “Oh God of my father-in-law Judah, I am a stranger to this tribe, but I have heard wonderful things about You. Lord of the universe, please listen to my prayer. I don’t know You yet, but I want to be Your servant. Er is in Your hands and so am I.”

Cautiously Tamar went into the adjacent room to check on her husband. Er was lying on his bed with his clothes still on. Tamar touched him and winced. His skin was cold and she could not see him breathing. She ran to her neighbors wailing: “My husband is dead! He’s dead!”

Then everything around her went black.

Word quickly spread and the family came together to sit Shiva with Tamar who was still in shock. The week after the burial, Judah came to see her father. Tamar knew the purpose of his visit. Her dead husband Er had two brothers – Onan and Shelah. According to oral law, Judah was obligated to marry one of his sons to Er’s widow so that his daughter-in-law had a provider and a chance to have children. The next in line was Onan.

Unlike his deceased brother, Onan was the quiet type. On their wedding day Tamar caught him staring at her in the most peculiar way. There was no smile on his face when they spoke their wedding vows. But the worst thing happened at night. ”No”, Tamar gasped. Onan withdrew in the middle of the act and spilled his semen on the ground, saying: “I’m not going to produce offspring for my loser-brother. He was a drunk.” Tamar felt dirty, used and abused. For the second time she was the unloved bride. “Don’t you want children and continue your father’s family line?” she asked. Onan didn’t even look at her when he responded: “I don’t care. My father should have talked to me first before forcing me to marry you.”

It was winter and the raining season had started. Tamar looked at the pouring rain outside her window and felt that the weather perfectly illustrated her feelings. She had been married to Onan for almost a year now and nothing had changed. Pouring out her heart to the Lord as had become her new custom, she prayed: “Oh God of Judah, I am a woman despised by two husbands and don’t know what to do. Please help me!”

Although it rained harder Tamar went outside. Looking up and down the road, her clothing was quickly drenched. She had expected Onan to be home by now, but some business seemed to have detained him.

Meanwhile, the weather had turned into a fierce thunderstorm. Tamar fled inside where she spent another sleepless night.   

In the morning there was no minor commotion when two strangers carried Onan into the village. “He got struck by a lightening”, one of them said. “We found him this morning not far from here. Are you Onan’s wife?” The whole village gasped as they saw Onan dead at Tamar’s feet, the second husband who had lost his life while being married to her. The mark of a lightning bolt was clearly visible on his back. Horrified, Tamar identified Onan: “Yes, this is my husband.”

The following days were like a whirlwind to Tamar. Her father-in-law was absolutely devastated. Avoiding eye contact he asked her to move back to her childhood home and live with her father for a while. “Tamar, you need to return to your father’s house. My son Shelah is too young,” he said, “we will have to wait until he is old enough to marry you.”

It was the last time Tamar would hear from Judah until many years later, on occasion of the annual sheep shearing festival. Judah and his friend Hirah were on their way to Timnah to shear their sheep and join the festivities.

Previous Post
Judah’s Exodus
Next Post
Tamar’s Choice