Genesis 37:17-18: “So Joseph went after his brothers and found them near Dothan. But they saw him in the distance, and before he reached them, they plotted to kill him.”
In search for good grazing land, the sons of Jacob liked to drive their sheep up north, sometimes as far as Shechem. As a result, they were often gone for long periods of time. Joseph grew up tending the flocks with his brothers. However, he had the habit of telling his father all the juicy details of anything that went wrong along the way. This would not bode well for him in days to come.
At his father’s request, Joseph sporadically stayed home and his brothers went sheepherding without him. On one such occasion Jacob sent Joseph after them to see how things were going and report back to him.
From afar the sons of Jacob saw Joseph approaching. Reuben whistled through his teeth to alert everybody: “Watch out! Here comes the dreamer!” – “He’s definitely not dreaming when he spies on us”, Gad scoffed. Although their father had retired from active sheepherding he apparently felt the need to check on his sons, which was a clear sign of distrust. Most of all, everybody resented his partiality for Joseph.
“I wished he was dead. He makes our life miserable”, Dan said with a frustrated sigh. “Let’s kill him”, Levi said. For a moment there was stunned silence. Levi looked around, saying: “Come on! We all want him out of the way. Today’s the perfect opportunity. Then we’ll see what comes of his dreams” – “I’d say we teach Joseph a lesson”, Reuben cautioned, wording his advice carefully, “let’s not do anything stupid!” Judah proposed: “Why don’t we throw him in that abandoned cistern over there? That’ll teach him a lesson or two.” Reuben nodded and said: “Agreed! But no one harms the boy!” In his mind Reuben planned to rescue Joseph and restore him to his father.
Tension had been building for so long that it had begun to define the sons of Jacob. And their anger exploded when they attacked their brother, stripped him of his ornate robe and bound his hands and feet.
Joseph, trying to break free, protested loudly: “What do you think you’re doing? Is this a joke? This is not funny! ” Meanwhile his brothers carried him to the empty cistern and threw him in. Then they sat down to eat. Eventually Joseph became increasingly anxious and pleaded for his life: “Brothers, please don’t leave me down here! I’m sorry for everything. Get me out of here!” Reuben said to his brothers: “I can’t sit here and listen to him crying. I’m going to check on the goats and will be back in a minute.”
Meanwhile, a caravan with Midianite merchants came by. Ishmaelites, who traded spices, balm and myrrh, were traveling along. The caravan was headed for Egypt. Judah said: “I have an idea. Why don’t we sell Joseph to the slave traders? That way we can get rid of him without any bloodshed.” – “You’re a genius”, replied Simeon. And so they pulled Joseph out of the cistern. For 20 shekels they sold him to an Ishmaelite trader.
The caravan had just departed when Reuben returned from his errand. He immediately went to the cistern and saw that it was empty. Tearing his clothes, he asked his brothers: “What happened? Where is the boy?” Nobody answered him at first; then Judah spoke up and said: “We sold the boy to merchants heading for Egypt.” Reuben’s face turned pale as he cried out: “What are we going to tell our father?” –“Of course we cannot tell him the truth”, Judah said, “We need to make it look like a wild animal killed him.”
So the brothers killed a goat, took Joseph’s coat, ripped it and dipped it in the goat’s blood. Later they presented the ripped and bloody coat to their father, saying: “We found this on our way home. Could this be Joseph’s coat?” Jacob immediately recognized the fabric and started weeping. He tore his clothes and said: “A wild animal must have killed my son. Oh Joseph! How could this happen to you? Joseph my son! My son Joseph!” And Jacob mourned for many days. Whenever his family tried to comfort him he would say: “My only hope is that I will see him again after I die. Oh, I wished I was dead already!” And so he wept for his son. He was inconsolable.
